On Strategy
Seattle production agency Wild Robot just joined the collective we're part of, Assembly, and they are putting on a comedy show over at their offices in a couple of weeks.
I had the priveledge of meeting their co-founder, Jon Sneider, and I think they are definitely onto the next level of video production (especially their session rooms where clients and agencies can edit together, or their Davinci Color Resolve room where they can do super detailed color grading (also with clients... so jealous!!)). He wrote a book called Hacking Advertising too, and it had some pretty good takes on industry topics.... including..... the whole "STRATEGY" thing.
Oh shit we're back!
As a former holdco strategist this hits home for me.
An agency should earn its strategy mandate by showing which decisions it can improve. The client already brings knowledge that would take an outsider years to acquire. The agency brings a different set of capabilities. Good work begins by understanding how those capabilities fit together.
Jon Sneider offers a useful provocation. In his public writing accompanying Hacking Advertising, he argues that agencies often sell strategy despite lacking the client’s full data and duplicating expertise already available inside the business. His proposed alternative directs more resources toward creative production and work in market. [1]
The implication deserves more scrutiny than an argument about expensive decks. If clients already understand much of what matters, agencies need a more precise account of their contribution. “We do strategy” tells a buyer very little about the decision being made, the expertise being supplied, or the uncertainty being reduced.
The client knows more and can still be wrong
A client may understand why a product exists, which customers are profitable, what procurement requires, and which promises the organization can actually keep. That knowledge places real limits on outside recommendations. A campaign built around a benefit operations cannot deliver is a poor recommendation, however persuasive the presentation.
But knowing the business and knowing how the business appears to customers are different accomplishments. A team can understand its product deeply while overestimating how much anyone else understands or cares about it. Internal language can become so familiar that no one notices it has stopped communicating.
An agency has its own blind spots. It can mistake a recognizable category pattern for a specific diagnosis. It can treat an unusual constraint as evidence that the client lacks ambition. It can recommend an idea because the idea fits its capabilities. Neither side deserves automatic authority across every decision.
A better division of responsibility follows the knowledge relevant to the question. Commercial priorities require the client’s business judgment. A communication problem requires expertise in audience, message, and medium. Customer response requires evidence from customers. These overlap, but treating them as interchangeable makes disagreements harder to resolve.
Integration is a substantial contribution
Robert Grant’s knowledge based theory of the firm describes organizations as mechanisms for integrating specialized knowledge. Its useful insight here is that productive coordination does not require one participant to possess everyone else’s expertise. [2]
Applied to agency relationships, that suggests a different ambition. The agency needs enough understanding to connect the client’s business knowledge with creative and technical judgment. It does not need to become a less informed version of the client’s leadership team.
Consider a hypothetical enterprise software company trying to expand beyond its established technical buyers. The client may know the sales cycle, margins, and implementation risks. The agency may see that the current story presumes a level of technical fluency the new buyer does not have. Working together, they can identify which benefits matter, what proof is credible, and how to make those benefits understandable.
That work can require real strategy. The agency might help choose an audience, expose a weak assumption, or establish a message hierarchy. Its contribution becomes easier to evaluate because it addresses a named decision. A generic discovery phase would be harder to justify if those decisions were already settled by credible evidence.
The brief should preserve what the client knows
Wesley Cohen and Daniel Levinthal describe absorptive capacity as the ability to recognize, assimilate, and use outside knowledge, supported by prior related knowledge. [3] This offers a useful lens for evaluating both sides of a client and agency relationship.
For an agency, relevant expertise should make it a better listener. It should recognize why a detail matters and know which question to ask next. A strategist who hears “our buyer is the CIO” should investigate who uses the product, who influences the purchase, and who can block it. Simply copying “CIO” into an audience slide adds little.
The client has a corresponding responsibility to provide access to evidence and to people who understand the problem. Agency expertise cannot compensate indefinitely for missing information or approvals that reverse decisions without explanation.
An effective brief should make existing knowledge usable. It should distinguish supported facts from assumptions, explain binding constraints, and name the decision that remains open. That allows research to address an actual gap. It also prevents the agency from presenting information supplied by the client as a new strategic discovery.
Execution reveals strategic problems
Separating strategy from execution too cleanly conceals how much thinking happens while work is made. A script can reveal that the value proposition is incomprehensible. A prototype can reveal that the service promise creates too much friction. A production estimate can reveal that the proposed idea cannot be sustained at the required frequency.
Bringing makers into those decisions early gives the team a chance to revise its assumptions before committing more money. It also gives creative expertise a legitimate role in shaping the direction rather than limiting it to expressing choices made elsewhere.
James March’s work on organizational learning distinguishes exploring new possibilities from exploiting established knowledge. His analysis warns that the short term appeal of refining what already works can weaken longer term adaptation. [4]
For agencies, the practical implication is to create room for both dependable delivery and deliberate experiments. Shipping more work is useful when it helps answer meaningful questions. Producing endless variations of a settled idea may improve efficiency while leaving the important assumption untouched.
The experiment also needs an appropriate measure. A higher click rate cannot, by itself, establish that a positioning decision is sound. Immediate conversion can miss effects on trust or future demand. Some decisions warrant customer research before production; others can be tested responsibly in market. The method should follow the question, the risk, and the time required to observe a result.
Strategy should have a decision and a stopping point
A strategy proposal should explain which consequential choice remains unresolved, what evidence could change that choice, and what the client will be able to do when the work is complete. That standard accommodates substantial research when the stakes justify it. It also permits a team with a sound brief to proceed directly to creative development.
Imagine a retailer whose retention is strong but whose acquisition has stalled. If the priority audience, offer, and economics are established, the agency may be most useful developing and testing creative. If those choices depend on outdated assumptions, producing content immediately may waste the production budget. The scope follows the condition of the evidence.
Commercial incentives matter here. A firm paid by the hour can earn more from an expanding process even when the client would benefit from a shorter one. A fixed fee can encourage premature closure if the scope is poorly designed. Clear deliverables, access requirements, and explicit decisions provide a more credible basis for accountability than any particular billing model.
The stopping point matters as much as the starting point. Strategy has done useful work when the team can make a justified choice and act on it. Reopening a settled question requires new evidence or a changed condition. Otherwise, recurring strategy becomes a cost of organizational indecision.
What this asks of an agency
For CROWN, the opportunity is to make strategic judgment visible through the work. Start with what the client knows. Establish where that knowledge is strong and where a question remains open. Bring the relevant people into the decision, then make something that carries the decision into the world.
That approach asks the agency to be confident about its craft and specific about its claims. It must be willing to challenge the client when evidence warrants it, and equally willing to proceed when the client has already done the thinking well.
The question worth putting to any agency is straightforward: Given what our organization already knows, which decision will your involvement improve? A convincing answer is the beginning of a strategy mandate.
CROWN SOCIAL |
Sources and scope
This essay develops an original argument for agency practice using the sources below. Sneider’s public article provides the starting point; this draft does not claim to summarize the full book. The academic papers supply conceptual foundations, rather than direct empirical tests of the proposed agency model. The business examples are hypothetical.
[1] Jon Sneider. I Managed $250M Ad Budgets at Microsoft. Hacking Advertising newsletter, October 7, 2025.
https://jonsneider.substack.com/p/i-managed-250m-ad-budgets-at-microsoft
[2] Robert M. Grant. Toward a knowledge based theory of the firm. Strategic Management Journal 17, special issue (1996), 109–122.
https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.4250171110
[3] Wesley M. Cohen and Daniel A. Levinthal. Absorptive Capacity: A New Perspective on Learning and Innovation. Administrative Science Quarterly 35, no. 1 (1990), 128–152.
https://doi.org/10.2307/2393553
[4] James G. March. Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning. Organization Science 2, no. 1 (1991), 71–87.
https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2.1.71



